Home > Pond Life > Protecting Your Pond Life From Predators

Protecting Your Pond Life From Predators

By: Dr Gareth Evans - Updated: 20 Oct 2018 | comments*Discuss
Dragon Flies Diving Beetles Herons Cats

There are probably few things quite so disheartening than having established your beautiful fish or wildlife pond only to see its inhabitants decimated at the claws, jaws and beaks of hungry predators. Sadly, whatever life your pond contains, there will be something which considers it a tasty snack. Some of the smaller predators are virtually impossible to keep out, so a certain amount of losses of fry and tadpoles will, sadly, always remain a constant part of pond-keeping. However, the odds are more in our favour with the larger diners who visit – and a spot of deterrence can often make all the difference.

Small but Persistent

Insects number amongst some of the most hungry and persistent mini-predators in the pond. While dragonflies darting above the water may be one of the most welcome sights of summer, their larvae make inroads into anything smaller than themselves which happens into range of their powerful, extensible jaws. Large enough to take young fish, tadpoles and even small newts with ease, they can have quite an effect on the pond – particularly since some species spend up to five years in the water before changing into their adult form.

The great diving beetle is another ferocious predator with a large appetite for small pond animals, both as a 4cm long adult and as larvae, which may even be a little larger. The young take about a year to develop into adults, which then are able to fly – usually at night – to find suitable homes. They tend to prefer densely planted ponds and often bury themselves in the sludge at the bottom during the worst of the winter.

Herons and Other Unwelcome Guests

Of the larger predators, the Grey Heron (Ardea cinera) is probably the biggest threat to frogs and fish being easily able to consume a third of a kilogram of either in a day – and double that if there are chicks to be fed – though foxes, cats and even dogs can also be a nuisance. Effective deterrence is the only practical way to deal with the herons, denying them the easy meal that they have come to collect. The most usual ways to do this involve making it physically impossible for them to get at the fish – though this is not easy given their wickedly long beaks – or stopping them being able to strike in comfort from a good vantage point on the bank.

Nets and grills across the pond are often used to good effect, keeping the bird out of striking distance and netting fences around the perimeter can also help, since herons typically land on the ground and then walk up to the pond to hunt. However, both of these solutions can sometimes be a little unsightly and spoil the look of the water feature. One way around this is to construct the fence out of twine, tied to suitable supports; alternatively a selection of manufacturers produce these as kits, which tend to look quite unobtrusive. A mini-electric fence specifically designed for pond protection is also now available, to reinforce the message with a bit of a jolt.

Other high-tech solutions include trip-wire activated scarers and audio devices triggered by Passive Infra Red (PIR) motion sensors, which reproduce the sound of a gunshot and a heron alarm call – though neither is likely to endear you to any close neighbours. At the other extreme – and a good deal quieter – an old-fashioned scarecrow may be just as effective, especially if the heron also sees real people around the pond from time to time. The one thing virtually guaranteed not to work, however, is to put a plastic heron alongside the water, in the mistaken belief that it will appear to be staking out its territory and so put off intruders. Sadly, this is more likely to draw every passing rival’s attention to the richness of spoils to be had for free!

Cats, foxes and even the occasional stray dog can sometimes also prove a problem. Strong grills and fences may also be helpful in deterring them, while the use of wobbly rocks around the pond margins is said to put off cats – though there is the danger that next door’s moggie simply dislodges them and they end up falling in the water.

A variety of deterrent devices are also available based on PIR sensors to trigger a response to the unwanted arrival. Automatic water-jets, such as the Contech Scarecrow, connect to a hosepipe and deliver a powerful squirt towards the intruder on detection, while ultrasonic devices, such as the Fox Repeller, are designed to produce sounds at a frequency that foxes – and cats – find unpleasant.

Keeping pond life safe from predators is always likely to require a fair bit of effort. However, if you do succeed in making life sufficiently difficult for the predators, the chances are they will be off looking for easier picking elsewhere and your precious fish, newts or frogs get to live another day.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
[Add a Comment]
For the third time now I've had my garden wildlife pond wrecked by foxes. This time they have dragged the pond pump out, bitten through the cable (again) and thus shorted out all our ground floor electrics. They had pulled out the pump hose so almost all the pond water had been pumped out, no idea if my fish ( green tench) have survived, too dark to tell at the moment as this has happened at 10:30 at night. Already cost me 2 pumps, tried to protect the cable by feeding through a reinforced hose but they just drag the pump out to get to the cable to chew it! Am in despair with them.
Otago - 20-Oct-18 @ 11:09 PM
Fishless - Your Question:
I awoke one morning to find 2 dead Koi of over 2 feet long, one with its head bitten off beside my pond and then discovered that all 16 of my Koi mostly 2ft long or more had been taken from my large deep pond. A fox would kill all the fish it could reach but leave most behind dead, I am 2 miles from a river so doubt it was otters, whatever the predator it must have entered the pond to catch all 16 fish, It is a mystery which has me totally baffled. Any ideas what the predator could have been?

Our Response:
How sad and distressing for you. We think the possible predators may have been minks as they are known to "frenzy kill" where many other predators will simply kill sufficient to feed themselves. We can't be sure however.
PondExpert - 12-Nov-15 @ 2:43 PM
I awoke one morning to find 2 dead Koi of over 2 feet long, one with its head bitten off beside my pond and then discovered that all 16 of my Koimostly 2ft long or more had been taken from my large deep pond. A fox would kill all the fish it could reach but leave most behind dead, I am 2 miles from a river so doubt it was otters, whatever the predator it must have entered the pond to catch all 16 fish, It is a mystery which has me totally baffled. Any ideas what the predator could have been?
Fishless - 11-Nov-15 @ 4:51 PM
@Luteric. This is often a shock but if there's no sign of them, then that does indicate that perhaps an animal such as a cat has taken them. Of course a bird likea heron may have also be around when you've not been aware of it. Try the deterrents suggested in the article if you decide to purchase more fish.
PondExpert - 23-Apr-15 @ 2:24 PM
I have a small raised pond, and was delighted to see my goldfish stock has increased to 7 with two 'babies' amongst the other goldfish. I've had no problem for the past 3 years but, to my horror, all but one very docile fish was noticeable yesterday - and today the water is clear but he has gone too.There's been a unknown cat prowling around my garden, might that be the answer?I'm devastated! There are no remains anywhere, and I would have noticed a heron.
Luteric - 21-Apr-15 @ 11:53 AM
I have two large ponds and they were full of specimen fish. I have lost a number of these large fish including carp and koi without satisfactory explanation. recently I saw at a distance what looked like a swimming rat or similar. it had a light coloured head and dark body. Could this be the consumer of my missing fish
alan - 13-Jul-12 @ 3:31 PM
I am a young beginner in fish ponds.I have two large ponds and have stocked with fingerings.Please guide how to take care of it.frogs are already in and am afraid they mind eat fingerings.Each pond hold a thousand.
paul - 12-Sep-11 @ 7:37 AM
Can herons land on raised ponds? We lost all our fish to RATS and have now taken the sunken pond out and replaced it with a raised one. We did have a heron visit the old pond when we first got the fish but then covered it with netting and have not seen him since but would like to know whether we need to cover the raised pond? Thanks
claretqueen - 17-Apr-11 @ 7:17 PM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • John54
    Re: Pond Design: Frequently Asked Questions
    I have a small water feature producing a rain effect into a round reservoir. I would like to plant it with some of…
    25 May 2019
  • tony
    Re: FAQ: Pond Plants and Planting
    I have a half barrel water feature 30 inch's in diameter, 18 inches deep. I find I am having to change the water bi monthly ,…
    23 May 2019
  • Joe
    Re: Filtering Your Pond
    Im planning to build a new raised pond and need some advice. Its gonna hold 7600 litres and koi carp but i was thinking of building a bog…
    15 May 2019
  • Joanne Thorp
    Re: Frogs and Frogspawn
    I had 2 ponds in my garden and have had frogs and newts for many years - I recently had to cover the top pond for safety and now the frogs…
    14 May 2019
  • Eiles
    Re: Ponds and Trees
    My husband is making a wildlife pond with butyle lining close to a Cotoneaster tree can he cut some roots to avoid the lining or will it kill the…
    12 May 2019
  • Aud
    Re: Dealing with Green Pond Water
    My small pond has turned very green and fish dying Have cleaned pump and filter and filled with tap water , some fish appear to…
    6 May 2019
  • Kendra
    Re: Managing Plant Overgrowth Within Your Pond
    I have a 1 1/2 - 2 acre pond that is seriously overgrown and has a lot of matter at the bottom that needs to be…
    4 May 2019
  • Liz
    Re: What Could be the Reason for all the Fish Dying?
    Would it do any harm to increase the size of the filter box now my fish are a lot bigger. The present…
    3 May 2019
  • Kath
    Re: Your Top Pond Questions Answered
    I lost all my frog spawn and damselfly larvae and found an infestation with water beeltes, Notonata spp. I caught 13 and now…
    28 April 2019
  • JessH198
    Re: Pond Life - Dragonflies and Their Relatives
    Hi, I have dragonfly larvae in my pond but over the last couple of days I am finding dead/ empty skins floating…
    21 April 2019